the young man
declared
atomic facts exist
each a state of affairs
whose logical thought
is pictured by language
in truthbearing form
dumbing down metaphysics
allowing to operate
nands upon fixed
mathematical sense
to shut down and out
noisy nonsense
and yet…
the old man
refuted his youth
declaring philosophy
is after all
mere scientistic
linguistic illusion
ill-equipped
for a priori
discovery
and so…
never before
and not again since
has such utterly
self-repudiant
impulse
so violently veered
a transcendent vehicle
carrying consummate
brilliance of mind
into wastelands of
quarantined intellect
well again it did happen to D. F. Wallace brilliant mind turned writer broken by depression then hanged by himself at hight of his intellectual glory . great post though
LikeLike
Indeed. The Wallace tragedy was a terrible loss to the world of fiction authors. I had only philosophers in mind.
LikeLike
Paul!!!! This was beautiful, and in not so many words.
This was quite an attack. Enjoyed it much.
LikeLike
What a wonderful comment. Thank you so much.
LikeLike
You are warmly welcome, P!
LikeLike
Wow! Though I confess to being a huge fan of later Wittgenstein (post-Tractatus, after his turn). I think his advocacy of philosophy as linguistic therapy is still applicable to most branches of metaphysics and the mostly odiferous “postmodern” and “deconstructionist” movements, with certain exceptions. As far as the analytic tradition goes, Bernard Williams is in my opinion the perfect balance between analytic rigor and skepticism on one hand, and Continental innovation on the other.
LikeLike
Ethics & the Limits of Philosophy is a masterpiece. No more morally astute voice than that of Bernie Williams, If by linguistic therapy you mean sharpening philosophic language, I’m with you. But I was never quite sold on the notion that abstract concepts ARE what prevailing language says they are.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Poesy plus Polemics.
LikeLike
Wonderful words so masterfully done
LikeLike
thank you dearly
LikeLike
“deep is that which cannot be said.” goes to read Sri Aurobindo poetry.
LikeLike
appreciate the profound citation
LikeLike